The reader gets the impression that the proles are really seen as insignificant in Oceania. The consequences for acting outside the accepted rules for both societies are designed to deter citizens from straying from the path to begin with and offer a fatal alternative to insurgence. The future of the privileged society depends on it, but not all revolts succeed. Sorry, but copying text is not allowed on this site. Therefore, the failure of the party to provide is transformed into a personal conflict between individual proles over the goods which are available. Literature , George Orwell.

He sees in the proles the continuation of human spirit and the only hope of rebellion. During her time, the mid twentieth century, women were still seen as nothing other than housewives. Our right to speak our own opinions must not be given to us; it must be earned. In , the government attempts to eliminate thoughtcrime by systematic revision of the English language into a new dialect called Newspeak. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here Even a slight inflection in the voice or a look of the eye can be construed as thoughtcrime.

Huxley thought that the truth would be drowned in irrelevance and that what we love will ruin us.

GVV – 1984, The Handmaid’s Tale and Unforgiven for Leaving Cert English Comparative #625Lab

They rebelled against the normal, they rebelled against what was thought to be correct, they rebelled against their tle did this in order to show the government and its followers what was wrong with their way of control. We are told the whole story from her point of view, experiencing events as she does and receiving her memories as she remembers them. By keeping the proles in a constant state of poverty, the party distracts them from higher political issues.


The Particicution begins likewith a loud, esasy sound — a whistle. The question remains however, what does it all mean? In utopian society he argues, only tue and repression of natural urges toward individualism achieve security and complacency. Russia and Oceania had become dysutopian, a perversion of Marxist utopian society.

comparative essay the handmaids tale and 1984

Email coomparative Address never made public. When a member of the proles shows the least sign of a superior intellect, they are immediately vaporized by the thought police.

In this moment, Winston Smith, the protagonist of the text, is in a room with other members of what is known as the record department where Winston works.

Winston sees them as the only hope for the future of mankind.

Authors create dystopias to comment on and criticise features of their own society. His small actions of rebellion were only out to benefit himself which is why he made no difference to the regime and which is why Big Brother won. The faint, disobedient remarks made by their characters suggest their hope in the future generations opposed to the present one.

Those who showed intelligence or potential for leadership were not elevated through the hierarchy of society into party positions, they were vaporized.

The Handmaid’s Tale vs 1984

Winston Smith, the tragic non-conformist main character works as a member of the party. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. This difference in narrative forms, as well, gives us a differing insight into the two characters.

These strata are arranged in a hierarchy which is very similar to the one seen inwith the minority controlling the majority.

comparative essay the handmaids tale and 1984

His character gave off quite a depressing emotion whereas Offred knew how to fit in her humour. At one point in the novel, he 198 around the room and tells himself who will be vaporized in the next few weeks.


Comparison of and the Handmaid’s Tale – words | Study Guides and Book Summaries

Personally, I feel that Offred is the more compelling character even if she seems to give up everything she was after starting her affair with Nick. You handmaods commenting using your Google account. In this moment, a cowboy known as English Bob comes to the town in search of a 1, dollar reward.

The party slogan of Ingsoc illustrates talf sense of contradiction which characterizes the novel Eroticism and instinctual urges are harnessed and controlled by the state, much as Christianity tries to control these urges.

In addition to this the fact that there are so many of these posters and the fixating look on the enormous face also shows great discomfort and stress. You may also like: Offred cannot even wander the streets without being with somebody else. She seems to have a love of words and frequently plays around with them along with their varying definitions.

Winston is more of a rebellious character; he is a risk takes. Sorry, but only registered users have full access. Inthe government attempts to eliminate thoughtcrime by systematic revision of the English language into a new dialect called Newspeak.

Socialist idealism in had turned to a total loss of individual freedom in exchange for false security and obedience to a totalitarian government, a dysutopia.